On Oct. 26, Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew held up his Indian status card and called for the Indian Act to be abolished.
“You have nothing to lose but your chains,” Kinew said at this year’s First Nations and First Ministers’ meeting in Ottawa, the first to be held in two decades. Kinew, who is Anishnaabe, called on First Nations and federal leaders to explore the idea of moving away from the act.
Prime Minister Mark Carney said he shared Kinew’s view, adding that his government is “committed to a process that moves Canada beyond the Indian Act.”
But Kinew’s call met with opposition from some First Nations leaders, who said it distracts from Ottawa’s efforts to fast track major infrastructure projects, which could affect Indigenous lands.
Some experts say moving beyond the act could significantly improve First Nations’ economic position and autonomy. But given the difficulty of reaching consensus, individual nations may need to find their own paths out of it.
“Unanimity is not required. You don’t need the agreement of 630 First Nations before anything can happen,” said Frances Abele, a senior research fellow at the Carleton Centre for Community Innovation.
Abele has spent years working with the Centre for First Nations Governance, which consults with First Nations on how to move beyond the Indian Act.
“Each nation will make its own decision on its own time, on what it does about the Indian Act,” Abele added.
Paternalistic
Enacted in 1876, the Indian Act is widely seen as both paternalistic and racist. It gave the federal government sweeping control over First Nations people’s identity, land and governance, and was later used to force children into residential schools.
The act has been amended numerous times since 1876. But the Crown continues to hold legal title to reserve lands, while First Nations get to use it for their benefit.
This structure makes it difficult for on-reserve First Nations people to accrue wealth or access loans, such as mortgages, because a bank cannot repossess the land if someone defaults.
Bob Joseph, author of the bestselling book 21 Things You May Not Know About the Indian Act, says he has personally faced challenges because of the act.
Joseph tried to buy reserve land in British Columbia through a long-term lease — a popular workaround of the Indian Act — but the process was so complicated he and his wife ultimately gave up.
“We have a residential real estate property and other properties. But we were trying to buy on-reserve, and we just had a lot of trouble,” Joseph said in an interview.
His experiences are shared by First Nations more generally, he says.
“There’s no collateral, right? How do you buy a business [when] you don’t own the land you live on?”
Kyra Wilson, grand chief of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs, says the Indian Act runs contrary to treaties signed both before and after the act took effect.
“[When you] look at the treaty promises, we said that we would be sharing the wealth of the land and the resources, and the key wording in that is sharing.
“And right now, that’s not currently what’s happening.”
Attempts at reform
Governments have tried to reform the act many times.
In a 1969 White Paper, then-minister of Indian Affairs Jean Chretien proposed abolishing the Indian Act entirely. The paper also called for cancelling existing Indigenous treaties and eliminating Indian legal status.
Chretien’s proposal was roundly rejected by First Nations, who published their own Red Paper in response.
“[The White Paper] was done without consultation with Indigenous people, and actually, it flew in the face of what they’d been recommending to the federal government,” said Abele, noting First Nations had called for greater self-governance, the ability to acquire title to reserve lands and the creation of community development corporations.
Another attempt at reform, the 2002 First Nations Governance Act, failed for the same reason, says Abele.
“That too was a top-down attempt to give First Nations a path out from under the act. And those are never going to work,” she said.
“It has to be … First Nations themselves, who lead the way out.”
One successful effort was the 1996 Framework Agreement on First Nations Land Management, which has been signed by 213 of Canada’s approximately 630 First Nations to date. It enables First Nations to create their own land codes that give them greater control over the land they live on.
Yet even under this framework, reserve land is still owned by the Crown, not individuals or the band.
David Leis, president and CEO of the Frontier Centre for Public Policy, a free market-oriented think tank, says the Indian Act needs to be ditched or fully reformed to afford First Nations greater say over their territory.
“The point is that you want to empower property rights for First Nations so that they can have the certainty to make decisions and the incentives to be able to build their own local economy appropriately,” he said.
“For outside investment, potentially as well, that could add to the community. But in the end, the community itself would have to decide what would be the boundaries around that.
“This doesn’t have to be a cookie cutter approach.”
Joseph, the author, notes a number of First Nations — including the Nisga’a Nation in Northern B.C. and the Whitecap Dakota Nation in Saskatchewan — have negotiated modern treaties with Ottawa to gain greater control over governance, finances and land management.
“The Nisga’a negotiated a treaty, in which they got rid of most of the Indian Act. And people ask me, does it work? Yeah, because we don’t hear much about it,” Joseph said.
The federal government is currently implementing 27 modern treaties with First Nations across the country.
Fiscal capacity
Frank Deer, a professor of education at the University of Manitoba, says some First Nations have managed to thrive by obtaining greater autonomy and pursuing business development on their reserves. His Kahnawake First Nation, near Montreal, is one such example, he says.
But Deer, a trained teacher, has seen remote First Nations communities that do not have the same opportunities for business development.
“Some opportunities aren’t always available on very remote First Nations … [who] really do depend upon the fiscal transfers acquired from the federal government,” he said.
“It’s not to suggest that they can’t work out something to help themselves … but it is something that we have to keep in mind.”
For Deer and Abele, Indian Act reforms must therefore also address funding reform.
The way federal funds are currently distributed to First Nations is highly problematic, says Abele.
“It usually comes in a way that doesn’t allow long-term planning,” she said, noting funding is typically delivered in one or two-year installments.
“So you can’t say, ‘In five years, we want to redo the road to the water plant. Or in five years, we want to rebuild the school.’”
Abele would like to instead see a funding framework that more closely resembles provincial equalization payments.
“What we need is a … transfer of fiscal capacity that allows fungibility and long-term planning,” she said.
For Wilson, of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs, getting more say over resources is also critical.
She says the 1930 Natural Resources Transfers Agreement — which gave Alberta, Manitoba and Saskatchewan control over Crown land and natural resources — has created significant problems for how Prairie-based First Nations receive funding.
“The whole issue about the NRTA is that the province believes that they have control and authority over lands and resources in the province, but that is not what the treaties … promised,” she said.
“We said we would share collectively the wealth of lands and resources. But yet we’re still within this box of the province and the feds making decisions for First Nations.”
‘Principles of subsidiarity’
Joseph says First Nations governance must also be addressed.
Currently, even if First Nations bands are elected by their members, the bands’ powers are limited and they ultimately answer to the federal government.
“Governance, we need to talk about it,” Joseph said.
“I don’t care if you stick with an elected chief in council. But if you have one of those, it should be accountable to the people, not Indian Affairs,” he said, referring to the department Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada.
Leis, of the Frontier Centre, agrees that local accountability is critical.
“[Y]ou want to pursue principles of subsidiarity that give authority as close to the people and as individuals as possible,” he said.
“And right now, we have a very paternalistic system because so much of the authority resides with [the federal government].”
Leis says Kinew deserves credit for putting the Indian Act and its problems back on the national agenda.
“I think he kind of cut through all the noise and reluctance to look at this issue by holding up his card that identifies him based on race rather than him as an individual.
“And I think that’s a humbling reality that Canada has a long system of segregating people in terms of race … I think this is an exciting opportunity to say, ‘How can we do better?’”
Abele says that while few would disagree with Kinew’s statements, the mixed response to his proposal shows just how much work still needs to be done.
“I recognized the thoughts, the ideas — [Kinew is] right about them,” said Abele.
“But the reaction tells us that there’s a lot more conversation that has to happen.”
