Psilocybin-containing mushrooms, gymnopilus purpuratus, in New Zealand; Dec. 28, 2020. | Mycellenz via wikipedia
Read: 5 min

When Liz joined her family for a psychedelic therapy session in March of 2023, she did not expect it would lead her to confront a painful part of her past.

After a psilocybin “journey” with her brothers and sister-in-law, the group gathered in what she calls a “big cuddle puddle.”

As everyone lay together, hugging and crying, Liz suddenly felt viscerally alarmed. 

“I was just really uneasy,” she recalled. “That was the first indication for me that there was some darkness.”

Liz, a woman in her mid-60s based in northern Canada, says that moment began a years-long process to understand what had happened to her as a child. Canadian Affairs is not disclosing Liz’s real identity because psilocybin remains largely illegal in Canada.

Over 13 psychedelic journeys with two different facilitators, fragments of Liz’s past began to emerge. These led her to believe she had been sexually abused by her father when she was a child.

“All of a sudden a lot of things started to make sense,” she said. 

Therapists say psychedelic therapy may help some survivors process trauma. But sources also caution that memories emerging during psychedelic experiences require careful interpretation.

“Healing happens in images, metaphors and stories,” said Heather Lee, a Colorado-based psychotherapist who specializes in psychedelic-assisted therapy for women over 50. 

“It is about working with the emotions of the journey’s material, not the literal material as fact.”

Missing pieces

By her early 60s, Liz had what many would consider an enviable life. 

She had retired in her mid-50s after a long nursing career, spent winters in Arizona with her husband, and was financially comfortable. 

Yet inside, she felt like she was unraveling. 

“I was drinking and eating myself into oblivion,” she said. “I was over 200 pounds. I felt like I was killing myself slowly.” 

Years earlier, Liz and one of her brothers had completed the Hoffman Process, a week-long personal development program that examines the lasting effects of childhood experiences. Both came away unsettled by how little they remembered.

“I had younger memory, and I had older adolescent memory, but … I really did not have childhood memory,” she said. “That was quite disconcerting.”

Trauma can disrupt memory, sometimes making parts of an experience difficult to recall or organize into a coherent narrative.

Dr. Ingrid Pacey, a retired psychiatrist who spent nearly 50 years treating women with post-traumatic stress disorder and complex trauma, says traumatic material often returns as “fragmented images, emotions and body sensations” rather than a complete narrative.

Liz herself notes that memory gaps are not proof of abuse on their own. But over a series of psychedelic journeys, she says a pattern began to emerge that pointed her toward the possibility of abuse.

There were no neat, “cinematic flashbacks.” Instead, she describes fragments — body sensations, family scenes — and small clues she noticed while sorting through old photos and letters.

“There was constantly stuff showing up in front of me that would make me go, hmm,” she says. “I would find different pieces here and different pieces there.”

Those pieces included memories of growing up in what she describes as a “very hypersexual” family.

Her father kept “a pile of Penthouse and Playboy” beside his chair in the living room, she says, while there were four teenage boys and a daughter in the house. He often took her out alone — “I would remember, ‘Oh yeah, we went to that rodeo’ … but that’s it.” 

Liz says she struggled with weight gain, body-image issues, alcohol use, difficult relationships and eventually chronic pain and an autoimmune disease.

“Why couldn’t I be happy?” she remembers asking. “What happened to me?”

A close friend who worked in child protection told Liz she saw parallels with the experiences she had observed among survivors of sexual violence.

Liz also believes one of her brothers may have been harmed. She said he has described a childhood memory of their father climbing into bed with him and touching him in a way that has stayed with him for decades.

“My feeling was that he was abused as well,” said Liz.

Lee, the Colorado-based psychotherapist, says many of her clients arrive with a feeling that “something is off” without being able to fully articulate why.

In the psychedelic therapy sessions she leads, Lee says those experiences can become material for exploring emotions and experiences that may be difficult to access through conventional talk therapy.

For Lee, the value is not necessarily in proving exactly what happened, but in identifying emotions or experiences that may still be affecting someone.

“These are the things that I see that no therapist in talk therapy would find,” said Lee. “These little nuggets of unhealed things that free us up.”

Memory and meaning

Memory researchers emphasize that memories are not recordings of past events. Memories are reconstructed each time they are recalled and can be shaped by emotions, expectations and new information.

Lee says therapists should approach clients’ memories with curiosity, focusing on the emotions they evoke rather than whether they can be independently verified.

“I encourage clients to just hold the information with open curiosity. It is about discovering how this image — this feeling — might be helpful in healing their present pain or helping them release or reframe a past trauma.

“It’s important not to look at that information as factual evidence.”

Researchers studying memory and psychedelics echo that caution.

In a 2025 review, researchers in Finland and Switzerland wrote that psychedelic experiences may heighten suggestibility and feelings of certainty, meaning “subjective feelings of ‘revealed truth’ … should not be mistaken as evidence for objective truth.”

They concluded there is currently no evidence that psychedelics reliably recover traumatic memories.

Studies of other psychoactive substances have also raised concerns about increased suggestibility and memory distortion.

Those concerns have practical implications. 

Sexual violence is widespread in Canada. According to Statistics Canada, over one-third of women and one-tenth of men have reported experiencing sexual assault in their lifetime.

Canadian law does not impose a time limit for coming forward with child sexual abuse claims.

Pacey, the retired psychiatrist, says therapists should avoid encouraging certainty or accusations after a single session. Instead, clients should work through emerging material gradually in ongoing psychotherapy, with careful screening, preparation and integration.

“The safest way to work with this really is in ongoing psychotherapy,” she said. “You don’t immediately jump to the conclusion that you know this is the whole story.”

If allegations are later reported to police, memories that emerged in therapy are not taken as proof that abuse occurred. Investigators and courts assess them alongside all other available evidence, with credibility and reliability remaining central issues.

“Premature conclusions and accusations of family members or others need to be explored,” said Pacey.

Healing without certainty

For Lee, healing does not depend on recovering a complete account of the past. The goal, she says, is helping people process the emotions and experiences that emerge in a way that improves their lives in the present.

“We are not on a mission of forensic psychology,” she said. “There is no verification needed. I try to frame the focus on: how does this insight or intuition help you on your healing journey for your own personal wellbeing?”

For many clients, Lee says, the value is not in proving exactly what happened, but recognizing that something in their past may still be affecting them.

“It is not about building a case and opening old wounds,” she said. “It is about tending your own healing here and now in a deeper psychospiritual way.”

Liz is quick to say she is still “a work in progress.” But after years of psychedelic sessions, therapy and reflection, she says her relationship with herself has changed.

She has kept about 35 pounds off, drinks less, and says her relationships have improved. She carries less shame and says her anger has softened.

“I am at peace with where I am in my life,” she said. “Now I don’t feel so desperate.”

She knows psychedelic therapy is not a simple answer and would not encourage others to pursue it without support.

“My indomitable little spirit would say, ‘Jump on it,’” she said. “However, my cautious adult would say, ‘Make sure you have supports in place … don’t do it alone, err on the side of safety’.”

Alexandra Keeler is a Toronto-based reporter focused on covering mental health, drugs and addiction, crime and social issues. Alexandra has more than a decade of freelance writing experience.

Leave a comment

This space exists to enable readers to engage with each other and Canadian Affairs staff. Please keep your comments respectful. By commenting, you agree to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We encourage you to report inappropriate comments to us by emailing contact@canadianaffairs.news.