The Air India Flight 182 Memorial in Toronto, Canada; Sept. 27, 2017. | Magnolia677, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikipedia
Read: 3 min

On Oct. 29, the federal government released The Plan for a Stronger Canada, its first national security strategy in more than 20 years. 

The plan names authoritarian aggression and foreign interference as threats that are now “immediate and proximate.” It commits to new legislation within a year; to a First Ministers’ Meeting on National Security; to a review of the entire national security enterprise; and an updated strategy every four years. 

The plan deserves praise — and is getting it. 

But it also has a critical gap: people. 

The plan is organized around eight strategic capabilities, from critical minerals to payment systems. Canadians appear mostly as a population to be defended. 

The Canadians whom foreign states and terrorist organizations have already harmed barely appear at all. The word “victim” appears once. “Terrorism” does not appear anywhere, nor does “antisemitism” — a month after the government itself declared antisemitism a matter of national security.

For Canadians harmed by foreign dictatorships and terrorist groups, the threats the plan describes arrived years ago.

Targets of transnational repression have been sounding the alarm for years, and living with the consequences of not being heard. 

Falun Gong practitioners in Toronto have been filmed by embassy staff at their own protests and had signs taken from their hands. 

Uyghur, Tibetan, Tamil, Eritrean, Tigrayan, Cuban, Iranian and Hong Kong Canadians have been threatened, followed, harassed online or told that relatives back home will answer for what they say here.

The plan recognizes the need to protect communities vulnerable to transnational repression. But that commitment lands on a legal system with no consistent definition of the term, no clear pathway for reporting incidents and no dedicated fund for those it harms. 

The legislation promised within the year is an opportunity to close those gaps. The communities on the receiving end should help write it.

The same is true for Canadians victimized abroad by terrorism and mass violence. 

In a report published in September with Secure Canada, Isabelle Terranova and I surveyed how these Canadians are treated. 

Survey respondents described being passed between Canadian and foreign services, as well as between Ottawa and the provinces; a federal system that treats what happens outside Canada as somebody else’s problem; and provincial victim services that treat them as outside their mandate. No federal body is responsible for them, and no document sets out what they are entitled to.

Canada’s national security strategy should be built hand-in-hand with the people it is meant to protect. This is not simply a matter of courtesy, but effectiveness. 

The reporting process the plan promises will work only if targeted communities help build it — because they are the ones who will decide whether to trust it.

The same logic applies to the plan’s intelligence commitments. 

It promises partnerships with the private sector and research institutions. Diaspora and civil society organizations belong on that list too. 

The plan’s promised review of oversight bodies should likewise include Canadians who have been harmed.

Consulting victims exposes gaps that are difficult to see from inside government. 

Families in our September survey learned only when they needed help that the federal fund for Canadians victimized abroad caps counselling at $5,000 over five years — an amount weekly sessions exhaust within months.

The fund excludes anyone victimized before April 2007, leaving the families of Air India Flight 182 and of Sept. 11 without support. 

None of these gaps were hidden, but each was invisible to anyone who had not fallen through it.

A national security strategy is written for a country, but it is tested on people. 

Canadians whom foreign state and non-state actors have already reached know where the system holds and where it gives way. 

A plan that writes them in — and keeps them in the room — will protect more Canadians than one that merely writes about them.

Sarah Teich is co-founder and president of Human Rights Action Group and represented the Human Rights Coalition before Canada’s federal Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference in Federal Electoral Processes...

Leave a comment

This space exists to enable readers to engage with each other and Canadian Affairs staff. Please keep your comments respectful. By commenting, you agree to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We encourage you to report inappropriate comments to us by emailing contact@canadianaffairs.news.