Sylvie Arnaud’s first feeling when she learnt her son Louis had been detained in Iran in September last year was sheer incredulity, followed by a raging sense of injustice and impotence.
“We don’t know how long this will last, we don’t know what the Iranians are waiting for and we will probably never know,” she said.
Louis Arnaud, described by his family as a passionate traveller who simply wanted to see the world, is one of four French nationals held in prison in Iran.
He is also among at least a dozen Western nationals jailed in what campaigners and some governments describe as a deliberate strategy of hostage-taking by the Islamic republic to extract concessions.
But Iran is far from the only country accused of pursuing such a strategy. China, Russia and Venezuela have also held innocent foreigners on trumped-up charges of espionage or other security-related allegations.
Precedents have shown the prisoners are generally only released in exchange for something — either for other detainees or assets — forcing Western governments into the uncomfortable position of negotiating over hostage-takings.
Such negotiations are hugely time-consuming, painstaking, often conducted through intermediaries and deals can collapse at the last minute.
‘Rewarding a crime’
Western governments have often made major concessions to secure the release of their nationals held abroad.
In recent days, the United States authorized the transfer of six billion dollars in Iranian funds frozen in South Korea and the release of five Iranians to facilitate the release of five Americans jailed by Iran.
After being released from prison, the Americans are now held under house arrest and should go home when the transaction is completed.
This exchange has already been criticized for not including two US residents: German national Jamshid Sharmahd who is facing the death penalty and Virginia-based Iranian Shahab Dalili who was arrested in 2016 while visiting Tehran.
At the end of May, Belgian humanitarian Olivier Vandecasteele was released after 15 months of detention in Iran, in exchange for an Iranian diplomat, Assadollah Assadi, who had been sentenced in Belgium in 2021 to 20 years in prison on terror charges for seeking to bomb an opposition rally outside Paris.
In October 2022, seven American prisoners held in Venezuela were released in exchange for two individuals close to President Nicolas Maduro.
In December, Russia released basketball superstar Brittney Griner, who had been held since February 2022 on charges of possessing vape cartridges with a small quantity of cannabis oil. She was released in exchange for notorious Russian arms dealer Viktor Bout — known as the “Merchant of Death” — who had been jailed in the United States.
But former US marine Paul Whelan, remains imprisoned in Russia, where he’s been held for more than four years. And in March, Russia arrested another US citizen, Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich.
In 2021, China released Canadians Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor in exchange for the United States reaching a deferred prosecution agreement for Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou. Beijing had detained Kovrig and Spavor in retaliation for Meng’s 2018 arrest.
Etienne Dignat, professor at Sciences Po university in Paris, said governments faced a “dilemma.”
“By unfreezing assets and exchanging prisoners, they are in a certain way rewarding a crime and encouraging states to continue their hostage diplomacy,” said Dignat, who is author of a book on hostage-taking.
‘Only way to get home’
Daren Nair, a security consultant and campaigner who runs a podcast on hostage diplomacy, said the number of victims has risen in recent years.
“The majority of Americans held captive abroad 10 years ago were held by non-state actors in countries like Syria, Yemen and Somalia… Today, the majority of Americans held captive abroad are being held by state actors like Iran, Venezuela, Russia and China.”
He said that once nationals are taken, governments have no alternative except to negotiate with their captors. He said more should be done to thwart the strategy in the first place.
He argued the two ways to stop hostage diplomacy were to “punish the individuals responsible within these hostage-taking states and continuously raise awareness so your citizens stop travelling to these countries.”
“In general the only way to get a hostage home is to negotiate,” said Joel Simon, founding director of the Journalism Protection Initiative. “Other strategies — such as rescues — are rarely successful.”
“Unless we engage with hostage takers — whether they be states or non-state actors — the hostage will probably be killed or will languish in detention or prison for an extended period.”
Blandine Briere never doubted the innocence of her brother Benjamin who was finally freed in May after being held for three years in Iran on charges of espionage.
She recalled how the family felt plunged into an “impasse.”
“We discovered a world that was unknown in normal life.”
